1880s 1890s 1900s 1910s 1920s 1930s 1940s 1950s 1960s 1970s 1980s 1990s 2000s 2010s 2020s
1882/83
| Date | Opponents | FT | V | Rd | Scorers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 13 Jan 1883 | Liverpool AFC | W | 8-0 | A | R1 | Jim Richards (3), Job Wilding (3), Joe Pickering, William Parry |
| 17 Feb 1883 | Liverpool Rovers | W | 6-0 | H | QF | Mike Higgins (2), Jack McGill, Henry Williams, William Williams, Frank Brettell |
| 31 Mar 1883 | Bootle (1879) | L | 1-3 | N | SF | James Cartwright (played at College Ground, Fairfield) |
1883/84
| Date | Opponents | FT | V | Rd | Scorers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 Nov 1883 | St Peter’s | W | 10-0 | H | R1 | Jack McGill (3), Willie Brown (2), AE Welsh, Mike Higgins, own goal, Henry Williams, Edwin Berry |
| 22 Dec 1883 | Liverpool Ramblers | W | 4-1 | A | R2 | Mike Higgins, Jack McGill, Henry Williams, William Gibson |
| 26 Jan 1884 | Bootle Wanderers | W | 5-2 | A | QF | William Gibson (2), Mike Higgins, Henry Williams, Jack McGill |
| Bye | SF | |||||
| 29 Mar 1884 | Earlestown | W | 1-0 | N | F | William Parry (played at Hawthorne Road) 🏆 |
1884/85
| Date | Opponents | FT | V | Rd | Scorers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 25 Oct 1884 | Toxteth Wanderers | W | 7-0 | H | R1 | William Gibson (3), Walter Richards (2), Joe Pickering, Mike Higgins |
| 20 Dec 1884 | Southport | W | 2-1 | A | R2 | Mike Higgins (2) |
| 31 Jan 1885 | Bootle (1879) | W | 2-1 | H | QF | Jack Whittle, William Parry (AET) |
| 21 Feb 1885 | Golborne | W | 9-0 | N | SF | Jack McGill (4), Walter Richards (2), William Gibson, William Finlay, Jack Whittle (played at Hawthorne Road) |
| 28 Feb 1885 | Earlestown | L | 0-1 | N | F | (played at Hawthorne Road) |
1885/86
| Date | Opponents | FT | V | Rd | Scorers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 24 Oct 1885 | Southport | W | 3-1 | H | R1 | George Dobson, Robert Gurley, George Farmer |
| 12 Dec 1885 | New Ferry | W | 14-0 | H | R2 | George Farmer (8), Job Wilding (2), William Finlay (2), Charlie McGoldrick, Tom Marriott |
| 27 Feb 1886 | High Park | W | 2-1 | A | QF | own goal, Walter Richards |
| 27 Mar 1886 | Stanley | W | 3-0 | N | SF | Job Wilding (2), William Finlay (played at Hawthorne Road) |
| 10 Apr 1886 | Bootle (1879) | W | 1-0 | N | F | Job Wilding (played at Walton Stiles) 🏆 |
1886/87
| Date | Opponents | FT | V | Rd | Scorers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 23 Oct 1886 | Bootle | W | 2-0 | A | R1 | William Briscoe, Walter Richards |
| 4 Dec 1886 | Haydock | W | 5-0 | H | R2 | George Fleming (2), Walter Richards (2), Andy Gibson |
| 19 Feb 1887 | Linacre | W | 13-1 | H | QF | George Farmer (5), William Briscoe (3), Walter Richards (2), Andy Gibson (2), Tommy Costley |
| 19 Mar 1887 | Tranmere | W | 9-1 | H | SF | George Farmer (3), Tommy Costley (2), William Briscoe (2), Walter Richards, Will George |
| 2 Apr 1887 | Oakfield Rovers | W | 5-0 | N | F | George Fleming (2), own goal, Tommy Costley, Andy Gibson (played at Hawthorne Road) 🏆 |
1887/88
| Date | Opponents | FT | V | Rd | Scorers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 24 Sep 1887 | Liverpool St John’s | W | 12-0 | H | R1 | Mike Higgins (4), Alec Dick (2), Andy Gibson (2), Walter Richards (2), Tommy Costley (2) |
| 3 Dec 1887 | Bootle | W | 2-0 | H | R2 | George Farmer, Andy Gibson |
Everton were expelled from the 1887/88 Liverpool Senior Cup as a consequence of their expulsion from the 1887/88 FA Cup due to professionalism.
1888/89
Everton did not participate in the 1888/89 Liverpool Senior Cup.
1889/90
| Date | Opponents | FT | V | Rd | Scorers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 25 Dec 1889 | Southport | W | 5-0 | H | QF | Fred Geary (3), Alf Milward (2) |
| 17 Mar 1890 | Earlestown | W | 13-2 | H | SF | Alec Brady (4), Fred Geary (4), Edgar Chadwick (2), Dan Kirkwood (2), Alf Milward |
| 9 Apr 1890 | Bootle (1879) | W | 4-0 | A | F | Edgar Chadwick (3), Alex Latta 🏆 |