1880s 1890s 1900s 1910s 1920s 1930s 1940s 1950s 1960s 1970s 2010s 2020s
1880/81
| Date | Opponents | FT | V | Rd | Scorers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6 Nov 1880 | Great Lever | L | 0-2* | A | R1 | |
| 27 Nov 1880 | Great Lever | L | 1-8 | A | R1r | Unknown |
*Match replayed after Everton protested the referee was a Great Lever member.
1881/82
| Date | Opponents | FT | V | Rd | Scorers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 22 Oct 1881 | Middleton | W | 5-0 | H | R1 | William Gibson (3), Jack McGill (2) (60 mins long) |
| 10 Dec 1881 | Turton | L | 1-3 | A | R2 | Unknown |
1882/83
| Date | Opponents | FT | V | Rd | Scorers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 Oct 1882 | Blackburn | L | 0-8 | A | R1 |
Everton did not participate in the Lancashire Senior Cup from 1883/84 to 1886/87 due to the club “be not allowed to play for the Senior Cup until they show proof of their ability” by the Lancashire FA. Everton participated in the Lancashire Junior Cup instead in 1885/86 and 1886/87.
1885/86
| Date | Opponents | FT | V | Rd | Scorers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 26 Sep 1885 | Adlington | W | 8-1 | H | R1 | Charles Jones (2), Robert Gurley (2), Walter Richards (2), Mike Higgins, William Finlay |
| 31 Oct 1885 | Peel Park | L | 1-5 | A | R2 | Unknown |
1886/87
| Date | Opponents | FT | V | Rd | Scorers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 Oct 1886 | Fleetwood Zingari | W | 9-0 | H | R1 | Crosby (3), Robert Gurley (2), William Briscoe, Tommy Costley, Mike Higgins, Walter Richards |
| 6 Nov 1886 | Bell’s Temperance | L | 2-3 | H | R2 | Mike Higgins (2) |
Everton return to the Lancashire Senior Cup.
1887/88
| Date | Opponents | FT | V | Rd | Scorers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Oct 1887 | Witton | L | 1-4 | H | R1 | George Farmer |
1888/89
| Date | Opponents | FT | V | Rd | Scorers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 29 Sep 1888 | Turton | W | 4-2 | H | R1 | William Briscoe (3), Tommy Costley |
| 10 Nov 1888 | Padiham | W | 2-0 | H | R2 | T. Cookson, Tommy Costley |
| 25 Dec 1888 | Blackburn Park Road | W | 3-2 | H | QF | Tom Fayer, William Harbour, George Farmer |
| 16 Mar 1889 | Higher Walton | L | 1-3 | N | SF | Edgar Chadwick (played at Leamington Road) |
1889/90
| Date | Opponents | FT | V | Rd | Scorers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6 Nov 1889 | Witton | W | 6-0 | H | R1 | Alex Latta (3), Alec Brady, Edgar Chadwick, Fred Geary |
| 14 Dec 1889 | Blackburn | W | 2-1* | H | R2 | F. Abbott, Dan Kirkwood |
| 28 Dec 1889 | Blackburn | D | 0-0 | H | R2r | |
| 20 Jan 1890 | Blackburn | L | 1-5 | A | R2r2 | Alf Milward |
*Abandoned due to fog, despite match being completed, and was replayed. Match became a reserve friendly match instead.