| Sunderland | 2 |
Johnny M. Campbell 10' Jock Scott 75' | |
| Everton | 1 |
Fred Geary 20' | |
HT: 1-1
Saturday 3 October 1891
KO: 15:15
Line-Up (2-3-5)
Average age: 24y 49d- GKDavid Jardine
- RBDuncan McLean
- LBWalter Campbell
- RHBob Kelso
- CHJohnny Holt ©
- LHAlex Lochhead
- ORAlex Latta
- IRPatrick Gordon
- CFFred Geary
- ILEdgar Chadwick
- OLAlf Milward