| Everton | 5 |
Jack Taylor 23' Bert Freeman 38' Sandy Young 50' Harry Makepeace 83' Walter White 86' | |
| Middlesbrough | 3 |
Sammy Cail 20' Alf Common 55' Steve Bloomer 65' | |
HT: 2-1
Wednesday 19 January 1910
1909/10 FA Cup first round replay
KO: 14:15
Line-Up (2-3-5)
Average age: 27y 342d- GKBilly Scott
- RBBob Clifford
- LBJock Maconnachie
- RHVal Harris
- CHJack Taylor
- LHHarry Makepeace
- ORJack Sharp ©
- IRWalter White
- CFBert Freeman
- ILSandy Young
- OLGeorge Barlow