| Newcastle United | 1 |
Albert Shepherd 2' | |
| Everton | 2 |
Harry Mountford 26' Bert Freeman 42' | |
HT: 1-2
Saturday 25 September 1909
KO: 15:30
Line-Up (2-3-5)
Average age: 28y 22d- GKBilly Scott
- RBBob Balmer
- LBJock Maconnachie
- RHVal Harris
- CHJack Taylor
- LHHarry Makepeace
- ORJack Sharp ©
- IRTim Coleman
- CFBert Freeman
- ILSandy Young
- OLHarry Mountford