| Everton | 5 |
Edgar Chadwick 30' Alf Milward ??' Alec Brady ??', ??' Fred Geary ??' | |
| Aston Villa | 0 |
HT: 2-0
Thursday 1 January 1891
KO: 14:30
Line-Up (2-3-5)
Average age: 23y 83d- GKDavid Jardine
- RBAndrew Hannah ©
- LBDan Doyle
- RHDan Kirkwood
- CHJohnny Holt
- LHCharlie Parry
- ORAlex Latta
- IRAlec Brady
- CFFred Geary
- ILEdgar Chadwick
- OLAlf Milward