| Everton | 3 |
Jimmy Settle 5' John Proudfoot 10', 23' | |
| Newcastle United | 2 |
Jock Peddie 7' Jack Fraser 37' (p) | |
HT: 3-2
Saturday 6 January 1900
KO: 14:30
Line-Up (2-3-5)
Average age: 24y 118d- GKWillie Muir
- RBGeorge Eccles
- LBBilly Balmer
- RHSam Wolstenholme
- CHJack Blythe
- LHWalter Abbott
- ORJack Sharp
- IRJack Taylor ©
- CFJohn Proudfoot
- ILJimmy Settle
- OLRobert Gray