| Notts County | 4 |
William Smith 3', 60' Jimmy Oswald 6' Teddy May ??' | |
| Everton | 3 |
Alf Milward 40', 65' Fred Geary ??' | |
HT: 2-1
Saturday 19 October 1889
KO: 15:10
Line-Up (2-3-5)
Average age: 22y 205d- GKBob Smalley
- RBAndrew Hannah ©
- LBDan Doyle
- RHCharlie Parry
- CHJohnny Holt
- LHGeorge Farmer
- ORAlex Latta
- IRDan Kirkwood
- CFFred Geary
- ILEdgar Chadwick
- OLAlf Milward