| Everton | 5 |
Fred Pickering 9', 43' Alex Young 40', 56', 86' | |
| Sheffield Wednesday | 1 |
John Fantham 66' | |
HT: 3-0
Tuesday 31 August 1965
KO: 19:30
Line-Up (4-2-4)
Average age: 25y 97d- 1GKGordon West
- 2RBTommy Wright
- 6CBBrian Harris
- 5CBBrian Labone ©
- 3LBRay Wilson
- 4RHJohn Hurst
- 10LHColin Harvey
- 7ORAlex Scott
- 8CFAlex Young
- 9CFFred Pickering
- 11OLDerek Temple