| Everton | 4 |
Roy Vernon 5', 62' Jimmy Harris 10' Mickey Lill 65' | |
| Preston North End | 0 |
HT: 2-0
Saturday 27 February 1960
KO: 15:15
Line-Up (2-3-5)
Average age: 25y 86d- 1GKAlbert Dunlop
- 2RBAlex Parker
- 3LBJohn Bramwell
- 4RHBrian Harris
- 5CHBrian Labone
- 6LHMick Meagan
- 7ORMickey Lill
- 8IRBobby Collins ©
- 9CFJimmy Harris
- 10ILRoy Vernon
- 11OLTommy Ring