| Everton | 1 |
Jimmy Harris 31' | |
| Burnley | 2 |
Jimmy McIlroy 35' (p) Brian Pilkington 75' | |
HT: 1-1
Wednesday 17 September 1958
KO: 19:00
Line-Up (2-3-5)
Average age: 26y 85d- 1GKJimmy O'Neill
- 2RBAllan Sanders
- 3LBJohn Bramwell
- 4RHJohnny King
- 5CHTE Jones ©
- 6LHBrian Harris
- 7ORJimmy Harris
- 8IRBobby Collins
- 9CFDave Hickson
- 10ILWally Fielding
- 11OLEddie O'Hara