| Everton | 3 |
Jackie Keeley 3', 93' Dave Hickson 106' | |
| Sunderland | 1 |
Charlie Fleming 24' | |
HT: 1-1
Wednesday 8 January 1958
1957/58 FA Cup third round replay
KO: 19:00
Line-Up (2-3-5)
Average age: 24y 316d- 1GKAlbert Dunlop
- 2RBAllan Sanders
- 3LBJimmy Tansey
- 4RHKen Rea
- 5CHTE Jones ©
- 6LHMick Meagan
- 7ORJimmy Harris
- 8IREddie Thomas
- 9CFDave Hickson
- 10ILJackie Keeley
- 11OLBrian Harris