| Aston Villa | 1 |
Jack Devey 16' | |
| Everton | 2 |
Jimmy Welford 19' (og) Edgar Chadwick 85' | |
HT: 1-1
Saturday 26 September 1896
KO: 15:30
Line-Up (2-3-5)
- GKFrank Briggs
- RBDavid Storrier
- LBSmart Arridge
- RHDickie Boyle
- CHJohnny Holt
- LHBilly Stewart ©
- ORJack Bell
- IRJack Taylor
- CFAbe Hartley
- ILEdgar Chadwick
- OLAlf Milward