| Everton | 3 |
Hugh Goldie 23' Abe Hartley 50', ??' | |
| Small Heath | 0 |
HT: 1-0
Monday 3 February 1896
KO: ??:??
Line-Up (2-3-5)
Average age: 26y 103d- GKJack Hillman
- RBJimmy Adams
- LBSmart Arridge
- RHDickie Boyle ©
- CHJohnny Holt
- LHBilly Stewart
- ORJack Bell
- IRHugh Goldie
- CFAbe Hartley
- ILEdgar Chadwick
- OLAlf Milward