| Everton | 5 |
Dixie Dean 6', 31' Ted Critchley 44' Jimmy Dunn 55', 61' | |
| Barnsley | 2 |
Jimmy Proudfoot 8', 66' | |
HT: 3-1
Wednesday 18 February 1931
KO: 15:15
Line-Up (2-3-5)
Average age: 27y 65d- GKBilly Coggins
- RBBen Williams ©
- LBWarney Cresswell
- RHJoe McClure
- CHCharlie Gee
- LHJock Thomson
- ORTed Critchley
- IRJimmy Dunn
- CFDixie Dean
- ILTommy "Tosh" Johnson
- OLJimmy Stein