| Liverpool | 2 |
Alan Arnell 21' Jimmy Melia ??' | |
| Everton | 1 |
Dave Hickson 12' | |
HT: 2-1
Wednesday 1 October 1958
Floodlight Challenge Cup
Line-Up
- Jimmy O'Neill
- Allan Sanders
- John Bramwell
- Johnny King
- TE Jones
- Brian Harris
- Andy Penman
- Jimmy Harris
- Dave Hickson
- Eddie Thomas
- Eddie O'Hara