| Everton | 5 |
George Farmer ??' George Fleming ??' William Briscoe ??' Job Wilding ??', ??' | |
| South Shore | 0 |
HT: 2-0
Saturday 25 September 1886
Friendly
Line-Up
- Charlie Jolliffe
- George Dobson
- Alec Dick
- Teddy Corey
- Andy Gibson
- Mike Higgins
- George Farmer
- Job Wilding
- William Briscoe
- Tommy Costley
- George Fleming