Everton players who have scored on their competitive debut for the club. (Excludes returning debuts.)
| Date | Player | Opponents | Competition | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 20 Oct 1888 | Tommy Costley | Derby | Football League | Scored two goals. Costley has played for Everton several times in the pre-League era, however this was his competitive debut. |
| 3 Nov 1888 | Walter Brown | Bolton | Football League | |
| 24 Nov 1888 | Shamrock Coyne | Burnley | Football League | |
| 7 Sep 1889 | Fred Geary | Blackburn | Football League | Scored two goals. Scored in his first two games for Everton. |
| 7 Sep 1889 | Charlie Parry | Blackburn | Football League | Scored in his first three games for Everton. |
| 5 Oct 1889 | William Marr Orr | Derby | Football League | His only appearance for the club. |
| 2 Nov 1889 | Alec Brady | Stoke | Football League | Scored two goals. |
| 6 Sep 1890 | Walter Campbell | West Brom | Football League | |
| 18 Mar 1893 | Abe Hartley | Wolves | First Division | |
| 9 Sep 1893 | Jack Southworth | Derby | First Division | |
| 16 Sep 1893 | Jack Walker | Aston Villa | First Division | |
| 16 Apr 1894 | Harry Reay | Bolton | First Division | |
| 1 Sep 1894 | Tom McInnes | Sheffield Wednesday | First Division | |
| 7 Jan 1895 | Bill Williams | Stoke | First Division | |
| 7 Sep 1895 | Albert Flewitt | Nottingham Forest | First Division | |
| 5 Oct 1895 | John Cameron | Sheffield United | First Division | |
| 5 Sep 1896 | Jack Taylor | The Wednesday | First Division | |
| 4 Sep 1897 | Laurie Bell | Bolton | First Division | Scored two goals. |
| 11 Sep 1897 | John Divers | Derby | First Division | |
| 1 Sep 1898 | John Proudfoot | Blackburn | First Division | Scored in his first two games for Everton. |
| 1 Sep 1898 | Harry Clark | Blackburn | First Division | |
| 8 Oct 1898 | Wilfred Oldham | Bolton | First Division | |
| 28 Apr 1900 | Joe Turner | Manchester City | First Division | Scored two goals. |
| 1 Sep 1903 | Harold Hardman | Blackburn | First Division | |
| 14 Oct 1905 | Frank Oliver | Notts County | First Division | Scored a hat-trick. Scored in his first two games for Everton. |
| 14 Apr 1906 | Thomas “Prescot” Jones | Derby | First Division | |
| 2 Nov 1907 | Harry Mountford | Nottingham Forest | First Division | Scored in his first two games for Everton. |
| 19 Sep 1908 | George Barlow | Middlesbrough | First Division | |
| 9 Apr 1909 | Bob Turner | Liverpool | First Division | |
| 19 Mar 1910 | Jimmy Gourlay | Chelsea | First Division | Scored in his first two games for Everton. |
| 11 Apr 1910 | Louis Weller | Blackburn | First Division | |
| 7 Jan 1911 | Ted Magner | Preston | First Division | Scored in his first two games for Everton. |
| 2 Sep 1911 | Andy Burton | Tottenham | First Division | |
| 6 Jan 1912 | Tommy Browell | Manchester United | First Division | Scored two goals. Scored in his first three games for Everton. |
| 26 Dec 1912 | James Brannick | Blackburn | First Division | Scored in his first two games for Everton. |
| 26 Dec 1912 | Sammy Simms | Blackburn | First Division | |
| 4 Oct 1913 | Tom Page | Middlesbrough | First Division | |
| 11 Oct 1913 | Lance Johnston | Sheffield United | First Division | |
| 18 Oct 1913 | Tom Nuttall | Derby | First Division | Scored two goals. |
| 6 Dec 1913 | Bobby Parker | The Wednesday | First Division | |
| 24 Jan 1914 | Joe Clennell | Aston Villa | First Division | |
| 1 Jan 1915 | Billy Kirsopp | Tottenham | First Division | Scored in his first two games for Everton. |
| 30 Aug 1919 | Tommy Mayson | Chelsea | First Division | His only appearance for the club. |
| 3 Sep 1919 | Bert Rigsby | Bradford Park Avenue | First Division | |
| 28 Feb 1920 | Joe Kearslake | Oldham | First Division | His only appearance for the club. |
| 2 Apr 1920 | John Blair | Derby | First Division | Scored two goals. |
| 5 Feb 1921 | Stan Davies | Manchester City | First Division | Scored in his first two games for Everton. |
| 4 Mar 1922 | Wilf Chadwick | Bradford City | First Division | Scored two goals. Scored in his first two games for Everton. |
| 20 Jan 1923 | Jack Cock | Stoke | First Division | |
| 5 Sep 1925 | David “DJ” Murray | Cardiff | First Division | |
| 5 Mar 1927 | Dick Forshaw | Newcastle | First Division | |
| 12 Mar 1927 | Tony Weldon | Leeds | First Division | Scored in his first three games for Everton. |
| 22 Oct 1927 | Tommy White | West Ham | First Division | Scored two goals. |
| 1 Jan 1931 | Charlie Gee | Bury | Second Division | |
| 19 Nov 1932 | Albert Geldard | Middlesbrough | First Division | Scored in his first two games for Everton. |
| 25 Mar 1933 | Nat Cunliffe | Aston Villa | First Division | |
| 29 Aug 1934 | Charlie Leyfield | Leicester | First Division | Scored in his first three games for Everton. |
| 11 Sep 1935 | Billy Hartill | Portsmouth | First Division | |
| 23 Nov 1935 | Stan Bentham | Grimsby | First Division | Scored two goals. |
| 18 Apr 1936 | Bunny Bell | Leeds | First Division | Scored in his first two games for Everton. |
| 13 Feb 1937 | Tommy Lawton | Wolves | First Division | Scored in his first two games for Everton. |
| 5 Jan 1946 | Harry Catterick | Preston | FA Cup | |
| 2 Nov 1946 | Jock Dodds | Grimsby | First Division | The only Everton player ever to score in his first four games for the club. |
| 21 Aug 1948 | Aubrey Powell | Newcastle | First Division | |
| 5 Mar 1949 | Jimmy McIntosh | Blackpool | First Division | Scored in his first two games for Everton. |
| 15 Apr 1953 | Derek Mayers | Bury | Second Division | Scored two goals. |
| 22 Aug 1956 | Bert Llewellyn | Blackpool | First Division | Scored in his first two games for Everton. |
| 19 Apr 1957 | William Haughey | Manchester City | First Division | |
| 26 Dec 1957 | Jackie Keeley | Bolton | First Division | |
| 13 Sep 1958 | Bobby Collins | Manchester City | First Division | |
| 18 Feb 1959 | Bobby Laverick | West Brom | First Division | |
| 2 Sep 1959 | Frank Wignall | Burnley | First Division | |
| 31 Oct 1960 | Keith Webber | Walsall | League Cup | |
| 19 Oct 1963 | Barrie Rees | West Ham | First Division | Scored in his first two games for Everton. |
| 14 Mar 1964 | Fred Pickering | Nottingham Forest | First Division | Scored a hat-trick. |
| 20 Aug 1966 | Alan Ball | Fulham | First Division | |
| 9 Jan 1971 | David Johnson | Burnley | First Division | Scored in his first two games for Everton. |
| 20 Mar 1971 | Mick Lyons | Nottingham Forest | First Division | |
| 6 Mar 1979 | Ross Jack | Middlesbrough | First Division | His only appearance for the club. |
| 29 Aug 1981 | Alan Ainscow | Birmingham | First Division | |
| 29 Aug 1981 | Alan Biley | Birmingham | First Division | Scored in his first two games for Everton. |
| 5 May 1984 | Rob Wakenshaw | Manchester United | First Division | |
| 22 Sep 1987 | Ian Wilson | Rotherham | League Cup | |
| 27 Aug 1988 | Tony Cottee | Newcastle | First Division | Scored a hat-trick. |
| 19 Mar 1991 | Robert Warzycha | Leeds | Full Members Cup | |
| 25 Aug 1992 | David Unsworth | Tottenham | First Division | |
| 15 Aug 1992 | Barry Horne | Sheffield Wednesday | Premier League | Everton’s first ever Premier League goal. |
| 17 Aug 1996 | Gary Speed | Newcastle | Premier League | |
| 10 Jan 1998 | Mickael Madar | Crystal Palace | Premier League | |
| 12 Jan 2003 | Brian McBride | Tottenham | Premier League | Scored in his first two games for Everton. |
| 10 Apr 2005 | James Vaughan | Crystal Palace | Premier League | Everton’s (and the Premier League’s) youngest ever goalscorer. |
| 19 Aug 2006 | Andy Johnson | Watford | Premier League | |
| 1 Sep 2007 | Yakubu | Bolton | Premier League | |
| 7 Feb 2009 | Jô | Bolton | Premier League | Scored two goals. |
| 28 Aug 2013 | Gerard Deulofeu | Stevenage | League Cup | |
| 21 Sep 2013 | Romelu Lukaku | West Ham | Premier League | |
| 16 Feb 2014 | Lacina Traore | Swansea | FA Cup | |
| 30 Aug 2014 | Samuel Eto’o | Chelsea | Premier League | |
| 15 Jan 2017 | Ademola Lookman | Manchester City | Premier League | |
| 11 Aug 2018 | Richarlison | Wolves | Premier League | Scored two goals. Scored in his first two games for Everton. |
| 30 Aug 2023 | Beto | Doncaster | League Cup |